← All changes | includes/seo/class-llms-txt-manager.php +281 -19 2.3.0 → 2.11.0 View file →

		@@ -90,9 +90,9 @@
90	90	],
91	91	'key_features' => [
92	92	'title' => 'Key Features',
93	93	'required' => true,
94		- 'description' => 'Main features and functionality of the website',
	94	+ 'description' => 'Main features and functionality of the website, one feature per line. Commas are part of a feature, not separators.',
95	95	'max_length' => 300
96	96	],
97	97	'architecture' => [
98	98	'title' => 'Architecture & Components',
		@@ -203,8 +203,20 @@
203	203	*/
204	204	private const DELIVERY_MODES = ['auto', 'static', 'dynamic'];
205	205
206	206	/**
	207	+ * One-time marker for {@see LLMs_Txt_Manager::maybe_migrate_legacy_key_features()}.
	208	+ *
	209	+ * Public so the activator can record it on a fresh install, which has no
	210	+ * value saved under the old comma rule and must never be migrated.
	211	+ *
	212	+ * @since 2.10.0
	213	+ * @var string
	214	+ */
	215	+ public const KEY_FEATURES_MIGRATION_OPTION = 'thinkrank_llms_key_features_migration';
	216	+ public const KEY_FEATURES_MIGRATION_VERSION = '1';
	217	+
	218	+ /**
207	219	* Business type templates for content generation
208	220	*
209	221	* @since 1.0.0
210	222	* @var array
		@@ -296,8 +308,13 @@
296	308	'validation' => [],
297	309	'file_info' => []
298	310	];
299	311
	312	+ // Generating from saved settings (the MCP ability passes an empty
	313	+ // payload) can happen before any admin request has run the upgrade,
	314	+ // so make sure a legacy comma list has been converted first.
	315	+ self::maybe_migrate_legacy_key_features();
	316	+
300	317	// Get current settings
301	318	$settings = $this->get_settings('site');
302	319
303	320	// Merge saved settings underneath the provided input so that empty or
		@@ -541,8 +558,18 @@
541	558	if ('static' === $mode || 'dynamic' === $mode) {
542	559	return $mode;
543	560	}
544	561
	562	+ // A root PHP cannot write to has no static path at all: publishing
	563	+ // would simply fail and /llms.txt would 404. The sitemap's `auto`
	564	+ // already resolves this way (#754); llms.txt did not, so on an
	565	+ // Apache/LiteSpeed host with a read-only root — a managed stack such as
	566	+ // Flywheel, where ABSPATH is the locked core folder — `auto` chose
	567	+ // static and then could not deliver it (#756).
	568	+ if (!wp_is_writable(ABSPATH)) {
	569	+ return 'dynamic';
	570	+ }
	571	+
545	572	// $is_apache also covers LiteSpeed, which reads .htaccess the same way.
546	573	if (empty($GLOBALS['is_apache'])) {
547	574	return 'dynamic';
548	575	}
		@@ -1232,12 +1259,11 @@
1232	1259	}
1233	1260
1234	1261	if (null !== $content) {
1235	1262	// Get content preview (first 200 characters) with size safety
1236		- $status['content_preview'] = substr($content, 0, 200);
1237		- if (strlen($content) > 200) {
1238		- $status['content_preview'] .= '...';
1239		- }
	1263	+ // substr()/strlen() count BYTES, so this cut a multibyte character
	1264	+ // in half and shipped an invalid UTF-8 sequence in the preview (#687).
	1265	+ $status['content_preview'] = \ThinkRank\Core\Seo_Text::trim_to_length($content, 200);
1240	1266	}
1241	1267
1242	1268	// Cache the result for 5 minutes to improve performance
1243	1269	set_transient($cache_key, $status, 5 * MINUTE_IN_SECONDS);
		@@ -1573,11 +1599,20 @@
1573	1599	}
1574	1600
1575	1601	// Check key features quality
1576	1602	if (!empty($user_input['key_features'])) {
1577		- $features = explode("\n", $user_input['key_features']);
1578		- $feature_count = count(array_filter($features, 'trim'));
	1603	+ // The same splitter the generated file uses, so the count reported
	1604	+ // here and the bullets written out can never disagree (#765).
	1605	+ $feature_count = count(self::split_key_features((string) $user_input['key_features']));
1579	1606
	1607	+ // A single line containing commas is ambiguous: it is either a
	1608	+ // legacy comma-separated list or one feature with a comma in it.
	1609	+ // Rather than guess and risk publishing "and Etsy" as a feature,
	1610	+ // say so and let the author decide.
	1611	+ if (self::looks_like_comma_list((string) $user_input['key_features'])) {
	1612	+ $validation['suggestions'][] = 'Put each key feature on its own line. Commas are treated as part of a feature, not as separators.';
	1613	+ }
	1614	+
1580	1615	if ($feature_count < 3) {
1581	1616	$validation['warnings'][] = 'Consider adding more key features (3-8 recommended) for comprehensive AI understanding';
1582	1617	$validation['score'] -= 10;
1583	1618	} elseif ($feature_count > 10) {
		@@ -2038,9 +2073,9 @@
2038	2073	],
2039	2074	'key_features' => [
2040	2075	'type' => 'string',
2041	2076	'title' => 'Key Features',
2042		- 'description' => 'Main features and functionality of your website',
	2077	+ 'description' => 'Main features and functionality of your website. One feature per line: a comma is treated as part of a feature, not as a separator.',
2043	2078	'default' => '',
2044	2079	'maxLength' => 500
2045	2080	],
2046	2081	'target_audience' => [
		@@ -2148,8 +2183,243 @@
2148	2183	return "> " . $description . "\n\n";
2149	2184	}
2150	2185
2151	2186	/**
	2187	+ * Split the Key Features field into individual features.
	2188	+ *
	2189	+ * One feature per line. Commas used to be delimiters too, which meant a
	2190	+ * single feature that happened to contain one — "Collect reviews from
	2191	+ * Trustpilot, Google, and Etsy" — was published as three bullets, one of
	2192	+ * them reading "and Etsy" (#765). Validation counted by newline only, so
	2193	+ * it reported one feature while the file showed three and never flagged
	2194	+ * the split.
	2195	+ *
	2196	+ * Commas are not a fallback delimiter even when the value has no newlines.
	2197	+ * A comma inside a feature is ordinary prose and far more likely than a
	2198	+ * deliberate comma-separated list, and guessing wrong publishes mangled
	2199	+ * text to the file AI crawlers read. A single-line value with commas is
	2200	+ * kept whole and validate_content_quality() suggests splitting it, which
	2201	+ * tells the user what to do instead of quietly deciding for them.
	2202	+ *
	2203	+ * The one splitter both generation and validation use, so the file and the
	2204	+ * feature count can no longer disagree.
	2205	+ *
	2206	+ * @since 2.10.0
	2207	+ *
	2208	+ * @param string $key_features Raw field value.
	2209	+ * @return string[] Trimmed features, empties removed.
	2210	+ */
	2211	+ public static function split_key_features(string $key_features): array {
	2212	+ $features = preg_split('/[\r\n]+/', $key_features);
	2213	+
	2214	+ if (!is_array($features)) {
	2215	+ return [];
	2216	+ }
	2217	+
	2218	+ $features = array_map('trim', $features);
	2219	+
	2220	+ return array_values(array_filter($features, static fn(string $f): bool => '' !== $f));
	2221	+ }
	2222	+
	2223	+ /**
	2224	+ * Whether a value looks like the old comma-separated list.
	2225	+ *
	2226	+ * One line, and a comma in it. That is either a legacy list saved before
	2227	+ * newlines became the delimiter, or a single feature containing a comma —
	2228	+ * indistinguishable from the outside, which is exactly why this prompts
	2229	+ * rather than splits.
	2230	+ *
	2231	+ * @since 2.10.0
	2232	+ *
	2233	+ * @param string $key_features Raw field value.
	2234	+ * @return bool
	2235	+ */
	2236	+ public static function looks_like_comma_list(string $key_features): bool {
	2237	+ $trimmed = trim($key_features);
	2238	+
	2239	+ if ('' === $trimmed || false !== strpbrk($trimmed, "\r\n")) {
	2240	+ return false;
	2241	+ }
	2242	+
	2243	+ return false !== strpos($trimmed, ',');
	2244	+ }
	2245	+
	2246	+ /**
	2247	+ * Turn a single-line comma list into one feature per line.
	2248	+ *
	2249	+ * Returns null when the value is not something to convert: it already has
	2250	+ * line breaks, has no comma, or reads as one feature containing a series.
	2251	+ *
	2252	+ * Only for text that was written under a comma rule: values saved before
	2253	+ * newlines became the only delimiter (see
	2254	+ * {@see self::maybe_migrate_legacy_key_features()}), and AI replies that
	2255	+ * ignored the one-per-line instruction. Typed input never goes through
	2256	+ * this; split_key_features() still keeps a comma inside a feature (#765).
	2257	+ *
	2258	+ * A series is the one shape the old rule demonstrably mangled: "Collect
	2259	+ * reviews from Trustpilot, Google, and Etsy" became three bullets, the
	2260	+ * last reading "and Etsy". So a value is left whole when a segment after
	2261	+ * the first opens with a conjunction (the Oxford form), or when the final
	2262	+ * segment carries one ("..., Google and Etsy", the form the field's own
	2263	+ * placeholder uses). A plain list that happens to end "X and Y" is left
	2264	+ * whole too; validation still suggests splitting it, and one intact bullet
	2265	+ * is the safer wrong answer than a sentence cut into fragments.
	2266	+ *
	2267	+ * A comma between digits ("1,000 templates") is a thousands separator,
	2268	+ * not a delimiter.
	2269	+ *
	2270	+ * @since 2.10.0
	2271	+ *
	2272	+ * @param string $key_features Raw value.
	2273	+ * @return string|null Newline-separated features, or null to leave as is.
	2274	+ */
	2275	+ public static function comma_list_to_lines(string $key_features): ?string {
	2276	+ if (!self::looks_like_comma_list($key_features)) {
	2277	+ return null;
	2278	+ }
	2279	+
	2280	+ $segments = preg_split('/\s*,(?!\d)\s*/', trim($key_features));
	2281	+
	2282	+ if (!is_array($segments)) {
	2283	+ return null;
	2284	+ }
	2285	+
	2286	+ $segments = array_values(array_filter(
	2287	+ array_map('trim', $segments),
	2288	+ static fn(string $s): bool => '' !== $s
	2289	+ ));
	2290	+
	2291	+ if (count($segments) < 2) {
	2292	+ return null;
	2293	+ }
	2294	+
	2295	+ foreach (array_slice($segments, 1) as $segment) {
	2296	+ if (preg_match('/^(?:(?:and|or|nor|plus)\b|&)/i', $segment)) {
	2297	+ return null;
	2298	+ }
	2299	+ }
	2300	+
	2301	+ if (preg_match('/\s(?:and|or|&)\s/i', (string) end($segments))) {
	2302	+ return null;
	2303	+ }
	2304	+
	2305	+ return implode("\n", $segments);
	2306	+ }
	2307	+
	2308	+ /**
	2309	+ * Coerce an AI reply for Key Features into the one-per-line field value.
	2310	+ *
	2311	+ * The prompt asks for one feature per line, but models still answer with a
	2312	+ * JSON array or a comma-separated line. An array went through
	2313	+ * sanitize_textarea_field() as '' and the field silently kept its old
	2314	+ * value; a comma line was published as a single bullet now that commas are
	2315	+ * not delimiters. Both are normalised to lines here, before sanitising.
	2316	+ *
	2317	+ * @since 2.10.0
	2318	+ *
	2319	+ * @param mixed $value Decoded `key_features` from the reply.
	2320	+ * @return string Sanitised, newline-separated features.
	2321	+ */
	2322	+ public static function normalize_ai_key_features($value): string {
	2323	+ if (is_array($value)) {
	2324	+ $features = [];
	2325	+ foreach ($value as $item) {
	2326	+ if (is_scalar($item)) {
	2327	+ $item = trim((string) $item);
	2328	+ if ('' !== $item) {
	2329	+ $features[] = $item;
	2330	+ }
	2331	+ }
	2332	+ }
	2333	+ $value = implode("\n", $features);
	2334	+ } elseif (!is_scalar($value)) {
	2335	+ return '';
	2336	+ }
	2337	+
	2338	+ $value = (string) $value;
	2339	+ $lines = self::comma_list_to_lines($value);
	2340	+
	2341	+ return sanitize_textarea_field(null === $lines ? $value : $lines);
	2342	+ }
	2343	+
	2344	+ /**
	2345	+ * Convert a Key Features value saved under the old comma rule, once.
	2346	+ *
	2347	+ * Up to 2.9.0 a comma separated features, so a site that saved
	2348	+ * "SEO audits, Schema markup, XML sitemaps" published three bullets. After
	2349	+ * #765 made newlines the only delimiter the same stored value regenerates
	2350	+ * as one bullet holding the whole line, a silent change to the file AI
	2351	+ * crawlers read. Rewriting the stored value as lines keeps that site's
	2352	+ * output what it was, in the form the field now documents.
	2353	+ *
	2354	+ * A migration rather than a runtime fallback on purpose: a fallback would
	2355	+ * keep treating commas as delimiters for every single-line value forever,
	2356	+ * which is the #765 bug. Here only values that were saved while commas
	2357	+ * really were delimiters are touched, exactly once; anything typed after
	2358	+ * this has run follows the new rule. comma_list_to_lines() still leaves a
	2359	+ * series such as the #765 value whole.
	2360	+ *
	2361	+ * Version-gated like Settings::retire_seeded_ai_provider(), and the marker
	2362	+ * is written first so a site that fails the write does not retry on every
	2363	+ * admin request. The activator records it on a fresh install.
	2364	+ *
	2365	+ * @since 2.10.0
	2366	+ *
	2367	+ * @return void
	2368	+ */
	2369	+ public static function maybe_migrate_legacy_key_features(): void {
	2370	+ if (get_option(self::KEY_FEATURES_MIGRATION_OPTION) === self::KEY_FEATURES_MIGRATION_VERSION) {
	2371	+ return;
	2372	+ }
	2373	+
	2374	+ update_option(self::KEY_FEATURES_MIGRATION_OPTION, self::KEY_FEATURES_MIGRATION_VERSION, true);
	2375	+
	2376	+ (new static())->migrate_stored_key_features();
	2377	+ }
	2378	+
	2379	+ /**
	2380	+ * Rewrite the stored Key Features as lines when it is a legacy comma list.
	2381	+ *
	2382	+ * @since 2.10.0
	2383	+ *
	2384	+ * @return bool True when a value was converted and saved.
	2385	+ */
	2386	+ public function migrate_stored_key_features(): bool {
	2387	+ $stored = $this->get_stored_settings('site');
	2388	+
	2389	+ if (!isset($stored['key_features']) || !is_string($stored['key_features'])) {
	2390	+ return false;
	2391	+ }
	2392	+
	2393	+ $lines = self::comma_list_to_lines($stored['key_features']);
	2394	+
	2395	+ if (null === $lines) {
	2396	+ return false;
	2397	+ }
	2398	+
	2399	+ // validate_settings() rejects a payload without `enabled`, so carry the
	2400	+ // stored flag along. Written through the base save, not this class's,
	2401	+ // which would also reconcile the delivery mode: a stored-value rewrite
	2402	+ // must not republish anything.
	2403	+ return $this->write_migrated_key_features([
	2404	+ 'enabled' => $stored['enabled'] ?? true,
	2405	+ 'key_features' => $lines,
	2406	+ ]);
	2407	+ }
	2408	+
	2409	+ /**
	2410	+ * Persist the converted value. Separate so tests can observe the write.
	2411	+ *
	2412	+ * @since 2.10.0
	2413	+ *
	2414	+ * @param array $settings `enabled` and `key_features`.
	2415	+ * @return bool
	2416	+ */
	2417	+ protected function write_migrated_key_features(array $settings): bool {
	2418	+ return parent::save_settings('site', null, $settings);
	2419	+ }
	2420	+
	2421	+ /**
2152	2422	* Build additional details section
2153	2423	*
2154	2424	* @since 1.0.0
2155	2425	*
		@@ -2167,18 +2437,10 @@
2167	2437	}
2168	2438
2169	2439	if (!empty($key_features)) {
2170	2440	$content .= "**Key Features:**\n";
2171		- // The UI field is a multi-line textarea and validation counts by
2172		- // newline, so split on newlines (and still tolerate commas) rather
2173		- // than commas only — otherwise newline-separated input collapses
2174		- // into one broken bullet.
2175		- $features = preg_split('/[\r\n,]+/', $key_features);
2176		- foreach ($features as $feature) {
2177		- $feature = trim($feature);
2178		- if (!empty($feature)) {
2179		- $content .= "- " . $feature . "\n";
2180		- }
	2441	+ foreach (self::split_key_features($key_features) as $feature) {
	2442	+ $content .= "- " . $feature . "\n";
2181	2443	}
2182	2444	$content .= "\n";
2183	2445	}
2184	2446
		@@ -2212,9 +2474,9 @@
2212	2474	$content .= "- [Technical Stack]({$website_url}): Built with {$stack}\n";
2213	2475	}
2214	2476
2215	2477	if (!empty($user_input['development_approach'])) {
2216		- $approach_summary = wp_trim_words($user_input['development_approach'], 10);
	2478	+ $approach_summary = \ThinkRank\Core\Seo_Text::trim_words($user_input['development_approach'], 10);
2217	2479	$content .= "- [Development Guidelines]({$website_url}): {$approach_summary}\n";
2218	2480	}
2219	2481
2220	2482	// Add robots.txt reference