PluginProbe
ThinkRank AI SEO – AI SEO Plugin for WordPress: Schema, XML Sitemaps, Meta Tags, Search Console & Local SEO / 2.12.0
ThinkRank AI SEO – AI SEO Plugin for WordPress: Schema, XML Sitemaps, Meta Tags, Search Console & Local SEO v2.12.0
2.12.0 2.11.0 2.10.0 2.9.0 2.8.0 2.7.0 2.6.0 2.5.0 2.4.0 2.3.0 2.2.0 2.1.1 2.1.0 2.0.2 2.0.1 2.0.0 1.32.0 1.31.0 1.30.0 1.29.0 1.28.0 1.27.0 1.26.0 1.25.0 trunk All 53 releases
← All changes | includes/seo/class-llms-txt-manager.php +976 -52 2.0.0 → 2.12.0 View file →
@@ -14,8 +14,13 @@
14 14 declare(strict_types=1);
15 15
16 16 namespace ThinkRank\SEO;
17 17
18 +// Prevent direct access
19 +if (!defined('ABSPATH')) {
20 + exit;
21 +}
22 +
18 23 // Ensure dependencies are loaded
19 24 if (!class_exists('ThinkRank\\SEO\\Abstract_SEO_Manager')) {
20 25 require_once THINKRANK_PLUGIN_DIR . 'includes/seo/class-abstract-seo-manager.php';
21 26 }
@@ -51,8 +56,27 @@
51 56 */
52 57 private bool $last_unpublish_failed = false;
53 58
54 59 /**
60 + * Message from the last save that switched delivery mode but could not move
61 + * the published document, or an empty string when the switch was clean.
62 + *
63 + * @since 2.1.0
64 + * @var string
65 + */
66 + private string $last_delivery_warning = '';
67 +
68 + /**
69 + * Whether the last save's delivery-mode switch failed outright, as opposed
70 + * to succeeding with a warning. Both set {@see delivery_switch_warning()},
71 + * and only one of them means /llms.txt is still on the old path.
72 + *
73 + * @since 2.1.0
74 + * @var bool
75 + */
76 + private bool $last_delivery_switch_failed = false;
77 +
78 + /**
55 79 * LLMs.txt content sections configuration
56 80 *
57 81 * @since 1.0.0
58 82 * @var array
@@ -66,9 +90,9 @@
66 90 ],
67 91 'key_features' => [
68 92 'title' => 'Key Features',
69 93 'required' => true,
70 - 'description' => 'Main features and functionality of the website',
94 + 'description' => 'Main features and functionality of the website, one feature per line. Commas are part of a feature, not separators.',
71 95 'max_length' => 300
72 96 ],
73 97 'architecture' => [
74 98 'title' => 'Architecture & Components',
@@ -119,8 +143,80 @@
119 143 */
120 144 private const HTACCESS_MARKER = 'ThinkRank llms.txt';
121 145
122 146 /**
147 + * Option holding the published llms.txt document.
148 + *
149 + * The published content lives here regardless of delivery mode, so the
150 + * dynamic route has an authoritative source that does not depend on a
151 + * physical file, and switching modes never loses the published document.
152 + *
153 + * @since 2.1.0
154 + * @var string
155 + */
156 + private const CONTENT_OPTION = 'thinkrank_llms_txt_content';
157 +
158 + /**
159 + * Option holding the Unix timestamp of the last publish.
160 + *
161 + * @since 2.1.0
162 + * @var string
163 + */
164 + private const PUBLISHED_AT_OPTION = 'thinkrank_llms_txt_published_at';
165 +
166 + /**
167 + * Option recording what the site's public URL really answers /llms.txt with.
168 + *
169 + * Shaped as ['home' => string, 'result' => 'charset'|'no_charset'|'unknown',
170 + * 'checked_at' => int] and keyed on the home URL, so a clone or a migration
171 + * re-checks instead of inheriting the verdict of the host it came from.
172 + *
173 + * @since 2.1.0
174 + * @var string
175 + */
176 + private const DELIVERY_PROBE_OPTION = 'thinkrank_llms_delivery_probe';
177 +
178 + /**
179 + * How long an inconclusive delivery check is left alone before retrying.
180 + *
181 + * A conclusive verdict stands until the document is published again; only
182 + * the "could not tell" answer — a blocked loopback, an HTTP-auth'd staging
183 + * site — is worth asking about a second time, and not often.
184 + *
185 + * @since 2.1.0
186 + * @var int
187 + */
188 + private const DELIVERY_PROBE_RETRY = DAY_IN_SECONDS;
189 +
190 + /**
191 + * Shown when the server answers the published file without a charset.
192 + *
193 + * @since 2.1.0
194 + * @var string
195 + */
196 + private const STATIC_CHARSET_WARNING = 'This server answers the published llms.txt without a character set, so accented characters and curly quotes arrive mis-decoded. Set Delivery Method to "Served by WordPress" to publish it as UTF-8.';
197 +
198 + /**
199 + * Delivery modes accepted by the `delivery_mode` setting.
200 + *
201 + * @since 2.1.0
202 + * @var string[]
203 + */
204 + private const DELIVERY_MODES = ['auto', 'static', 'dynamic'];
205 +
206 + /**
207 + * One-time marker for {@see LLMs_Txt_Manager::maybe_migrate_legacy_key_features()}.
208 + *
209 + * Public so the activator can record it on a fresh install, which has no
210 + * value saved under the old comma rule and must never be migrated.
211 + *
212 + * @since 2.10.0
213 + * @var string
214 + */
215 + public const KEY_FEATURES_MIGRATION_OPTION = 'thinkrank_llms_key_features_migration';
216 + public const KEY_FEATURES_MIGRATION_VERSION = '1';
217 +
218 + /**
123 219 * Business type templates for content generation
124 220 *
125 221 * @since 1.0.0
126 222 * @var array
@@ -212,8 +308,13 @@
212 308 'validation' => [],
213 309 'file_info' => []
214 310 ];
215 311
312 + // Generating from saved settings (the MCP ability passes an empty
313 + // payload) can happen before any admin request has run the upgrade,
314 + // so make sure a legacy comma list has been converted first.
315 + self::maybe_migrate_legacy_key_features();
316 +
216 317 // Get current settings
217 318 $settings = $this->get_settings('site');
218 319
219 320 // Merge saved settings underneath the provided input so that empty or
@@ -279,10 +380,18 @@
279 380 * @return bool
280 381 */
281 382 public function save_settings(string $context_type, ?int $context_id, array $settings): bool {
282 383 $this->last_unpublish_failed = false;
384 + $this->last_delivery_warning = '';
385 + $this->last_delivery_switch_failed = false;
386 + $previous_mode = $this->resolve_delivery_mode();
387 +
283 388 $result = parent::save_settings($context_type, $context_id, $settings);
284 389
390 + // The cached status carries the resolved delivery mode, so it goes stale
391 + // the moment settings change — even when nothing needs republishing.
392 + delete_transient('thinkrank_llms_file_status');
393 +
285 394 // When a save explicitly disables the feature, delete the published file.
286 395 if ($result && array_key_exists('enabled', $settings) && empty($settings['enabled'])) {
287 396 if (!$this->delete_llms_txt_file()) {
288 397 // The settings were persisted, but the physical file could not be
@@ -289,14 +398,124 @@
289 398 // removed, so /llms.txt may still be served. Record it so callers
290 399 // report a partial failure instead of an unqualified success.
291 400 $this->last_unpublish_failed = true;
292 401 }
402 +
403 + return $result;
293 404 }
294 405
406 + // The published document has to sit where the active mode serves it from,
407 + // or the site keeps answering on the old path: a leftover physical file
408 + // shadows the dynamic route on every stack, and a database-only document
409 + // is invisible to a stack now expecting a file. Reconciled on any save,
410 + // not just an explicit mode change, so a site whose auto-detection now
411 + // resolves differently — an nginx install upgrading into this fix with a
412 + // static file already on disk — heals the next time settings are saved.
413 + if ($result && $this->delivery_needs_reconcile($previous_mode)) {
414 + $this->republish_for_delivery_mode();
415 + }
416 +
295 417 return $result;
296 418 }
297 419
298 420 /**
421 + * Whether the published document is out of step with the active mode.
422 + *
423 + * @since 2.1.0
424 + *
425 + * @param string $previous_mode Mode in force before the save.
426 + * @return bool
427 + */
428 + private function delivery_needs_reconcile(string $previous_mode): bool {
429 + $mode = $this->resolve_delivery_mode();
430 + $file_exists = file_exists(ABSPATH . 'llms.txt');
431 +
432 + if ('dynamic' === $mode) {
433 + // A physical file would be served instead of the PHP route.
434 + return $file_exists;
435 + }
436 +
437 + // Static: a stored document with no file behind it is unreachable on a
438 + // stack that expects one. A mode flip also forces the charset block to
439 + // be (re)written for a file that predates it.
440 + return (!$file_exists && '' !== trim($this->get_published_content()))
441 + || $mode !== $previous_mode;
442 + }
443 +
444 + /**
445 + * Re-publish the current document under the active delivery mode.
446 + *
447 + * A no-op when nothing is published yet — this only moves an existing
448 + * document, it never publishes on the user's behalf.
449 + *
450 + * @since 2.1.0
451 + *
452 + * @return void
453 + */
454 + private function republish_for_delivery_mode(): void {
455 + $content = $this->get_published_content();
456 +
457 + if ('' === trim($content)) {
458 + // Published before the stored copy existed: recover it from the file.
459 + $llms_file = ABSPATH . 'llms.txt';
460 + if (file_exists($llms_file)) {
461 + $read_result = $this->safe_file_read($llms_file);
462 + if ($read_result['success']) {
463 + $content = $read_result['content'];
464 + }
465 + }
466 + }
467 +
468 + if ('' === trim($content)) {
469 + return;
470 + }
471 +
472 + $write = $this->write_llms_txt_to_file($content);
473 +
474 + // The switch itself failed (an unwritable root on the way to static, a
475 + // stuck file on the way to dynamic). The settings are saved, so report
476 + // it rather than letting the mode read as applied when it is not.
477 + if (empty($write['success'])) {
478 + $this->last_delivery_warning = isset($write['message']) && '' !== (string) $write['message']
479 + ? (string) $write['message']
480 + : 'The delivery method was saved, but the published llms.txt could not be moved to it.';
481 + $this->last_delivery_switch_failed = true;
482 + return;
483 + }
484 +
485 + // The switch worked, but static delivery on this server cannot carry the
486 + // charset the document needs. Only an explicitly chosen `static` gets
487 + // this far — `auto` moves itself to WordPress delivery instead.
488 + if (!empty($write['delivery_warning'])) {
489 + $this->last_delivery_warning = (string) $write['delivery_warning'];
490 + }
491 + }
492 +
493 + /**
494 + * Message from the last save whose delivery-mode switch could not be
495 + * applied to the already-published document, or '' when there was none.
496 + *
497 + * @since 2.1.0
498 + *
499 + * @return string
500 + */
501 + public function delivery_switch_warning(): string {
502 + return $this->last_delivery_warning;
503 + }
504 +
505 + /**
506 + * Whether the last save's warning was a failed switch rather than a
507 + * successful one the server cannot serve correctly.
508 + *
509 + * @since 2.1.0
510 + *
511 + * @return bool
512 + */
513 + public function delivery_switch_failed(): bool {
514 + return $this->last_delivery_switch_failed;
515 + }
516 +
517 + /**
299 518 * Whether the last save_settings() disabled the feature but could not remove
300 519 * the published llms.txt file (which may therefore still be served).
301 520 *
302 521 * @return bool
@@ -305,15 +524,360 @@
305 524 return $this->last_unpublish_failed;
306 525 }
307 526
308 527 /**
309 - * Remove the published llms.txt file and bust the status transient.
528 + * Resolve the effective delivery mode for /llms.txt.
310 529 *
311 - * @return bool True if the file is absent or was removed.
530 + * `static` publishes a physical ABSPATH/llms.txt and lets the web server
531 + * answer it; `dynamic` keeps the document in the database and lets the PHP
532 + * route in {@see serve_llms_txt()} answer it. `auto` picks static only on
533 + * Apache/LiteSpeed, the stacks that read the .htaccess charset block — on
534 + * nginx a physical file is served with a bare `Content-Type: text/plain`
535 + * that neither fix path can reach, which renders UTF-8 as mojibake (#419).
536 + *
537 + * $is_apache is not trusted on its own: WordPress reads it from
538 + * $_SERVER['SERVER_SOFTWARE'], which describes the server that runs PHP
539 + * rather than the one answering the public request. A reverse proxy hides
540 + * the difference — an nginx edge in front of an Apache backend reports
541 + * Apache, so `auto` chose the file that nginx then served with no charset,
542 + * which is the very defect the setting was added to avoid (#493). A
543 + * publish-time self-request settles what the detection cannot see, and its
544 + * verdict is what this consults; an explicit setting still wins outright.
545 + *
546 + * @since 2.1.0
547 + *
548 + * @param string|null $mode Optional. Raw setting value; read from the saved
549 + * settings when null.
550 + * @return string Either 'static' or 'dynamic'.
312 551 */
552 + public function resolve_delivery_mode(?string $mode = null): string {
553 + if (null === $mode) {
554 + $settings = $this->get_settings('site');
555 + $mode = (string) ($settings['delivery_mode'] ?? 'auto');
556 + }
557 +
558 + if ('static' === $mode || 'dynamic' === $mode) {
559 + return $mode;
560 + }
561 +
562 + // A root PHP cannot write to has no static path at all: publishing
563 + // would simply fail and /llms.txt would 404. The sitemap's `auto`
564 + // already resolves this way (#754); llms.txt did not, so on an
565 + // Apache/LiteSpeed host with a read-only root — a managed stack such as
566 + // Flywheel, where ABSPATH is the locked core folder — `auto` chose
567 + // static and then could not deliver it (#756).
568 + if (!wp_is_writable(ABSPATH)) {
569 + return 'dynamic';
570 + }
571 +
572 + // $is_apache also covers LiteSpeed, which reads .htaccess the same way.
573 + if (empty($GLOBALS['is_apache'])) {
574 + return 'dynamic';
575 + }
576 +
577 + // Detection says this stack reads the .htaccess charset block. Believe
578 + // it unless a self-request has caught the public URL answering without
579 + // a charset, which is what a reverse-proxied stack does (#493).
580 + return $this->static_delivery_drops_charset() ? 'dynamic' : 'static';
581 + }
582 +
583 + /**
584 + * Whether the recorded check caught the public URL dropping the charset.
585 + *
586 + * @since 2.1.0
587 + *
588 + * @return bool
589 + */
590 + private function static_delivery_drops_charset(): bool {
591 + return 'no_charset' === ($this->delivery_probe()['result'] ?? '');
592 + }
593 +
594 + /**
595 + * The delivery check recorded for this site, or [] when there is none.
596 + *
597 + * @since 2.1.0
598 + *
599 + * @return array
600 + */
601 + private function delivery_probe(): array {
602 + $probe = get_option(self::DELIVERY_PROBE_OPTION, []);
603 +
604 + if (!is_array($probe) || !isset($probe['result'])) {
605 + return [];
606 + }
607 +
608 + return ($probe['home'] ?? '') === home_url() ? $probe : [];
609 + }
610 +
611 + /**
612 + * Ask the site's own public URL what it answers /llms.txt with.
613 + *
614 + * @since 2.1.0
615 + *
616 + * @return string 'charset', 'no_charset', or 'unknown' when the response
617 + * could not be read and nothing should be concluded from it.
618 + */
619 + private function probe_static_delivery(): string {
620 + if (!function_exists('wp_remote_get')) {
621 + return 'unknown';
622 + }
623 +
624 + // The cache-buster stops a page cache from answering with a copy stored
625 + // before the file was written; a server ignores the query string when it
626 + // serves a physical file, so the response still shows the real headers.
627 + $url = add_query_arg(
628 + 'thinkrank-delivery-check',
629 + (string) time(),
630 + home_url('/llms.txt')
631 + );
632 +
633 + $response = wp_remote_get($url, [
634 + 'timeout' => 5,
635 + 'redirection' => 2,
636 + // A request to our own home URL, from which a single response header
637 + // is read. Staging and local installs routinely run on certificates
638 + // this host does not trust, and failing there would leave the very
639 + // sites most likely to be misconfigured unchecked.
640 + 'sslverify' => false,
641 + 'headers' => ['Cache-Control' => 'no-cache'],
642 + ]);
643 +
644 + if (is_wp_error($response) || 200 !== (int) wp_remote_retrieve_response_code($response)) {
645 + return 'unknown';
646 + }
647 +
648 + $content_type = wp_remote_retrieve_header($response, 'content-type');
649 +
650 + // A header sent more than once comes back as an array.
651 + if (is_array($content_type)) {
652 + $content_type = implode(' ', $content_type);
653 + }
654 +
655 + $content_type = trim((string) $content_type);
656 +
657 + // No Content-Type at all is the same problem: the browser is left to
658 + // guess the encoding.
659 + if ('' === $content_type) {
660 + return 'no_charset';
661 + }
662 +
663 + return false !== stripos($content_type, 'charset=') ? 'charset' : 'no_charset';
664 + }
665 +
666 + /**
667 + * Persist the outcome of a delivery check.
668 + *
669 + * @since 2.1.0
670 + *
671 + * @param string $verdict One of 'charset', 'no_charset', 'unknown'.
672 + * @return void
673 + */
674 + private function record_delivery_probe(string $verdict): void {
675 + update_option(self::DELIVERY_PROBE_OPTION, [
676 + 'home' => home_url(),
677 + 'result' => $verdict,
678 + 'checked_at' => time(),
679 + ], false);
680 + }
681 +
682 + /**
683 + * Confirm the published file is really served with a charset, and act on it.
684 + *
685 + * Static delivery leans on an .htaccess directive, so it is only ever as
686 + * good as the guess that the server reads .htaccess. This checks the guess
687 + * against the response the public URL actually returns: a site left on
688 + * `auto` is moved to WordPress delivery when the charset is missing — the
689 + * file has to go with it, or it would shadow the PHP route that carries the
690 + * charset — while a site that asked for `static` keeps its file and gets a
691 + * warning, because an explicit choice is not overruled.
692 + *
693 + * @since 2.1.0
694 + *
695 + * @param array $result Publish result to annotate.
696 + * @return array The annotated result.
697 + */
698 + private function verify_static_delivery(array $result): array {
699 + $verdict = $this->probe_static_delivery();
700 +
701 + $this->record_delivery_probe($verdict);
702 +
703 + if ('no_charset' !== $verdict) {
704 + return $result;
705 + }
706 +
707 + $settings = $this->get_settings('site');
708 + $explicit = 'static' === (string) ($settings['delivery_mode'] ?? 'auto');
709 +
710 + // Auto: resolve_delivery_mode() answers 'dynamic' from here on, so the
711 + // file it would otherwise leave behind has to be removed. The document
712 + // is already stored, so nothing is lost by deleting it.
713 + if (!$explicit && $this->delete_static_file()) {
714 + delete_transient('thinkrank_llms_file_status');
715 + $this->purge_llms_txt_caches();
716 +
717 + $result['delivery_mode'] = 'dynamic';
718 + $result['charset_pinned'] = true;
719 + $result['message'] = 'LLMs.txt published. This server answers a static file without a character set, so WordPress serves it as UTF-8 instead.';
720 + $result['permissions']['file_exists'] = false;
721 + $result['permissions']['file_writable'] = null;
722 +
723 + return $result;
724 + }
725 +
726 + $result['charset_pinned'] = false;
727 + $result['delivery_warning'] = self::STATIC_CHARSET_WARNING;
728 + $result['message'] = trim((string) $result['message'] . ' ' . self::STATIC_CHARSET_WARNING);
729 +
730 + return $result;
731 + }
732 +
733 + /**
734 + * Whether the delivery check may run on this request.
735 + *
736 + * It makes an HTTP request of its own, so it never runs on a front-end
737 + * page view — only where an administrator, the REST API, WP-CLI or cron is
738 + * already waiting on a status read.
739 + *
740 + * @since 2.1.0
741 + *
742 + * @return bool
743 + */
744 + private function delivery_probe_is_due(): bool {
745 + $interactive = is_admin()
746 + || (defined('REST_REQUEST') && REST_REQUEST)
747 + || (defined('WP_CLI') && WP_CLI)
748 + || (function_exists('wp_doing_cron') && wp_doing_cron());
749 +
750 + if (!$interactive) {
751 + return false;
752 + }
753 +
754 + $probe = $this->delivery_probe();
755 +
756 + if ([] === $probe) {
757 + return true;
758 + }
759 +
760 + if ('unknown' !== $probe['result']) {
761 + return false;
762 + }
763 +
764 + return (time() - (int) ($probe['checked_at'] ?? 0)) > self::DELIVERY_PROBE_RETRY;
765 + }
766 +
767 + /**
768 + * The published llms.txt document, or an empty string when unpublished.
769 + *
770 + * @since 2.1.0
771 + *
772 + * @return string
773 + */
774 + public function get_published_content(): string {
775 + $content = get_option(self::CONTENT_OPTION, '');
776 +
777 + return is_string($content) ? $content : '';
778 + }
779 +
780 + /**
781 + * Whether /llms.txt is currently being served, in either delivery mode.
782 + *
783 + * `static` publishes a file at ABSPATH; `dynamic` keeps the document in
784 + * an option and answers from serve_llms_txt(). Callers that only need
785 + * this yes/no must use it in preference to get_llms_txt_status(), which
786 + * resolves the delivery mode, may fire a loopback delivery probe, asks
787 + * the filesystem API whether ABSPATH is writable, reads the document and
788 + * writes a transient — far too much work for a boolean, and not
789 + * something a dashboard summary should be triggering.
790 + *
791 + * @since 2.2.1
792 + *
793 + * @return bool
794 + */
795 + public function is_published(): bool {
796 + return file_exists(ABSPATH . 'llms.txt')
797 + || '' !== trim($this->get_published_content());
798 + }
799 +
800 + /**
801 + * Ask the common page/CDN cache layers to drop their copy of /llms.txt.
802 + *
803 + * A cached response outlives a republish, so without this a mode switch or
804 + * a content change keeps serving the old document (and, on the static path,
805 + * the old headers).
806 + *
807 + * The layer-by-layer work moved to Cache_Purger in 2.10.1, once alt-text
808 + * writes needed the same thing (#763). The llms.txt-specific hook stays
809 + * here because it names this document, which a generic URL purge cannot.
810 + *
811 + * @since 2.1.0
812 + *
813 + * @return void
814 + */
815 + private function purge_llms_txt_caches(): void {
816 + $url = home_url('/llms.txt');
817 +
818 + /**
819 + * Fires after the published llms.txt changes, so cache layers ThinkRank
820 + * does not know about can drop their copy.
821 + *
822 + * @since 2.1.0
823 + *
824 + * @param string $url Public URL of the llms.txt document.
825 + */
826 + do_action('thinkrank_llms_txt_updated', $url);
827 +
828 + Cache_Purger::purge_urls([$url]);
829 + }
830 +
831 + /**
832 + * Unpublish llms.txt: drop the stored document and any physical file.
833 + *
834 + * Both delivery modes are cleared, not just the active one, so a site that
835 + * published under one mode and switched to the other is left with nothing
836 + * still being served.
837 + *
838 + * @return bool True once nothing is left to serve.
839 + */
313 840 public function delete_llms_txt_file(): bool {
841 + delete_option(self::CONTENT_OPTION);
842 + delete_option(self::PUBLISHED_AT_OPTION);
843 +
844 + return $this->unpublish_static_file();
845 + }
846 +
847 + /**
848 + * Stop serving llms.txt, but keep the document.
849 + *
850 + * Deactivation needs this half: the physical file must go — it shadows the
851 + * next plugin's routes and advertises a plugin that is switched off — but
852 + * the user's prose has to survive so reactivation can republish it.
853 + * {@see \ThinkRank\Core\Activator::restore_webroot_artifacts()} does that.
854 + *
855 + * Deactivation previously called {@see delete_llms_txt_file()}, which drops
856 + * the stored document too, so a deactivate/reactivate round-trip silently
857 + * lost whatever the user had written.
858 + *
859 + * @since 2.1.0
860 + *
861 + * @return bool True once nothing is left on disk.
862 + */
863 + public function unpublish_static_file(): bool {
314 864 delete_transient('thinkrank_llms_file_status');
315 865
866 + $removed = $this->delete_static_file();
867 + $this->purge_llms_txt_caches();
868 +
869 + return $removed;
870 + }
871 +
872 + /**
873 + * Remove the physical ABSPATH/llms.txt and its .htaccess charset block.
874 + *
875 + * @since 2.1.0
876 + *
877 + * @return bool True if the file is absent or was removed.
878 + */
879 + private function delete_static_file(): bool {
316 880 $llms_file = ABSPATH . 'llms.txt';
317 881 if (!file_exists($llms_file)) {
318 882 $this->remove_htaccess_charset();
319 883 return true;
@@ -445,9 +1009,12 @@
445 1009
446 1010 $content = '';
447 1011 $llms_file = ABSPATH . 'llms.txt';
448 1012
449 - if (file_exists($llms_file)) {
1013 + // In static mode a physical file is what the server would normally hand
1014 + // back, so prefer its exact bytes; in dynamic mode there is no file and
1015 + // the stored document is the authoritative copy.
1016 + if ('static' === $this->resolve_delivery_mode() && file_exists($llms_file)) {
450 1017 $read_result = $this->safe_file_read($llms_file);
451 1018 if ($read_result['success']) {
452 1019 $content = $read_result['content'];
453 1020 }
@@ -453,8 +1020,12 @@
453 1020 }
454 1021 }
455 1022
456 1023 if ('' === trim($content)) {
1024 + $content = $this->get_published_content();
1025 + }
1026 +
1027 + if ('' === trim($content)) {
457 1028 $generated = $this->generate_llms_txt([]);
458 1029 $content = (string) ($generated['content'] ?? '');
459 1030 }
460 1031
@@ -496,10 +1067,39 @@
496 1067 $result['message'] = 'LLMs.txt is disabled. Enable it before publishing.';
497 1068 return $result;
498 1069 }
499 1070
1071 + $mode = $this->resolve_delivery_mode();
1072 + $result['delivery_mode'] = $mode;
1073 +
500 1074 $llms_file = ABSPATH . 'llms.txt';
1075 + $result['file_path'] = $llms_file;
501 1076
1077 + // Dynamic delivery: the document lives in the database and /llms.txt is
1078 + // answered by serve_llms_txt(), which sets `charset=utf-8` itself. A
1079 + // physical file would shadow that route on every stack, so any leftover
1080 + // from a previous static publish has to go.
1081 + if ('dynamic' === $mode) {
1082 + if (!$this->delete_static_file()) {
1083 + $result['message'] = 'A physical llms.txt is still present and could not be removed. It would be served instead of the dynamic route.';
1084 + return $result;
1085 + }
1086 +
1087 + $this->store_published_content($content);
1088 +
1089 + $result['success'] = true;
1090 + $result['message'] = 'LLMs.txt published. It is served by WordPress as UTF-8 text.';
1091 + $result['bytes_written'] = strlen($content);
1092 + $result['charset_pinned'] = true;
1093 + $result['permissions'] = [
1094 + 'directory_writable' => $this->is_directory_writable(ABSPATH),
1095 + 'file_exists' => false,
1096 + 'file_writable' => null,
1097 + ];
1098 +
1099 + return $result;
1100 + }
1101 +
502 1102 // Security: Validate file path to prevent path traversal attacks
503 1103 $real_llms_file = realpath(dirname($llms_file)) . DIRECTORY_SEPARATOR . basename($llms_file);
504 1104 $allowed_dir = realpath(ABSPATH);
505 1105
@@ -507,10 +1107,8 @@
507 1107 $result['message'] = 'Invalid file path detected for security reasons.';
508 1108 return $result;
509 1109 }
510 1110
511 - $result['file_path'] = $llms_file;
512 -
513 1111 // Check directory permissions
514 1112 $result['permissions'] = [
515 1113 'directory_writable' => $this->is_directory_writable(ABSPATH),
516 1114 'file_exists' => file_exists($llms_file),
@@ -528,36 +1126,57 @@
528 1126 $result['message'] = 'Existing llms.txt file is not writable. Please check file permissions.';
529 1127 return $result;
530 1128 }
531 1129
532 - // Write new content using WP_Filesystem
533 - if (!$this->init_filesystem()) {
534 - $result['message'] = 'Could not initialize WordPress filesystem.';
535 - return $result;
536 - }
1130 + // Write new content using WP_Filesystem
1131 + if (!$this->init_filesystem()) {
1132 + $result['message'] = 'Could not initialize WordPress filesystem.';
1133 + return $result;
1134 + }
537 1135
538 - $write_success = $this->filesystem->put_contents($llms_file, $content, FS_CHMOD_FILE);
1136 + if (!$this->filesystem->put_contents($llms_file, $content, FS_CHMOD_FILE)) {
1137 + $result['message'] = 'Failed to write llms.txt file.';
1138 + return $result;
1139 + }
539 1140
540 - if ($write_success) {
541 - $result['success'] = true;
542 - $result['message'] = 'LLMs.txt file written successfully.';
543 - $result['bytes_written'] = strlen($content);
1141 + $result['success'] = true;
1142 + $result['message'] = 'LLMs.txt file written successfully.';
1143 + $result['bytes_written'] = strlen($content);
544 1144
545 - // Pin the served charset to UTF-8. Best effort: a site without a
546 - // writable .htaccess (or not on Apache/LiteSpeed) still gets a
547 - // correctly written file, so this must never fail the publish.
548 - $result['charset_pinned'] = $this->sync_htaccess_charset();
1145 + // Pin the served charset to UTF-8. Best effort: a site without a
1146 + // writable .htaccess (or not on Apache/LiteSpeed) still gets a
1147 + // correctly written file, so this must never fail the publish.
1148 + $result['charset_pinned'] = $this->sync_htaccess_charset();
549 1149
550 - // Invalidate file status cache since file has changed
551 - delete_transient('thinkrank_llms_file_status');
552 - } else {
553 - $result['message'] = 'Failed to write llms.txt file.';
554 - }
1150 + // Keep the stored copy in step with the file so a later switch to
1151 + // dynamic delivery serves the same document.
1152 + $this->store_published_content($content);
555 1153
556 - return $result;
1154 + // Detection said this server reads the .htaccess block. Check what the
1155 + // public URL really answers with before leaving the file in place — on a
1156 + // reverse-proxied stack the detection describes the wrong server (#493).
1157 + return $this->verify_static_delivery($result);
557 1158 }
558 1159
559 1160 /**
1161 + * Persist the published document and bust the caches that mirror it.
1162 + *
1163 + * @since 2.1.0
1164 + *
1165 + * @param string $content Published llms.txt content.
1166 + * @return void
1167 + */
1168 + private function store_published_content(string $content): void {
1169 + update_option(self::CONTENT_OPTION, $content, false);
1170 + update_option(self::PUBLISHED_AT_OPTION, time(), false);
1171 +
1172 + // Invalidate file status cache since the published document has changed
1173 + delete_transient('thinkrank_llms_file_status');
1174 +
1175 + $this->purge_llms_txt_caches();
1176 + }
1177 +
1178 + /**
560 1179 * Get LLMs.txt file status and information
561 1180 *
562 1181 * @since 1.0.0
563 1182 *
@@ -574,36 +1193,69 @@
574 1193 }
575 1194 }
576 1195
577 1196 $llms_file = ABSPATH . 'llms.txt';
1197 + $mode = $this->resolve_delivery_mode();
578 1198
1199 + // A site that published before this check existed — or whose server has
1200 + // changed under it — has never had its delivery confirmed. Do it here so
1201 + // an already-broken install heals without waiting for a republish; the
1202 + // recorded verdict and the status cache keep it to a couple of requests
1203 + // a day at most.
1204 + if ('static' === $mode && file_exists($llms_file) && $this->delivery_probe_is_due()) {
1205 + $this->verify_static_delivery(['message' => '']);
1206 + $mode = $this->resolve_delivery_mode();
1207 + }
1208 +
1209 + $stored = $this->get_published_content();
1210 +
579 1211 $status = [
580 1212 'file_exists' => file_exists($llms_file),
581 - 'file_path' => $llms_file,
1213 + // Whether /llms.txt is actually being served, either mode. Prefer
1214 + // this over file_exists, which is only meaningful in static mode.
1215 + 'published' => $this->is_published(),
1216 + 'delivery_mode' => $mode,
1217 + 'file_path' => 'dynamic' === $mode ? '' : $llms_file,
582 1218 'file_url' => home_url('/llms.txt'),
583 1219 'writable' => $this->is_directory_writable(dirname($llms_file)),
1220 + // Non-empty only when the site is on static delivery that the server
1221 + // is known to answer without a charset — i.e. an explicit `static`
1222 + // the plugin will not overrule, which is the user's to fix.
1223 + 'delivery_warning' => 'static' === $mode && $this->static_delivery_drops_charset()
1224 + ? self::STATIC_CHARSET_WARNING
1225 + : '',
584 1226 'last_modified' => null,
585 1227 'file_size' => null,
586 1228 'content_preview' => ''
587 1229 ];
588 1230
1231 + $content = null;
1232 +
589 1233 if ($status['file_exists']) {
590 1234 $status['last_modified'] = filemtime($llms_file);
591 1235 $status['file_size'] = filesize($llms_file);
592 1236
593 - // Get content preview (first 200 characters) with size safety
594 1237 $read_result = $this->safe_file_read($llms_file);
595 1238 if ($read_result['success']) {
596 - $status['content_preview'] = substr($read_result['content'], 0, 200);
597 - if (strlen($read_result['content']) > 200) {
598 - $status['content_preview'] .= '...';
599 - }
1239 + $content = $read_result['content'];
600 1240 } else {
601 1241 $status['content_preview'] = 'Error: ' . $read_result['error'];
602 1242 $status['read_error'] = $read_result['error'];
603 1243 }
1244 + } elseif ('' !== trim($stored)) {
1245 + $published_at = (int) get_option(self::PUBLISHED_AT_OPTION, 0);
1246 + $status['last_modified'] = $published_at > 0 ? $published_at : null;
1247 + $status['file_size'] = strlen($stored);
1248 + $content = $stored;
604 1249 }
605 1250
1251 + if (null !== $content) {
1252 + // Get content preview (first 200 characters) with size safety
1253 + // substr()/strlen() count BYTES, so this cut a multibyte character
1254 + // in half and shipped an invalid UTF-8 sequence in the preview (#687).
1255 + $status['content_preview'] = \ThinkRank\Core\Seo_Text::trim_to_length($content, 200);
1256 + }
1257 +
606 1258 // Cache the result for 5 minutes to improve performance
607 1259 set_transient($cache_key, $status, 5 * MINUTE_IN_SECONDS);
608 1260
609 1261 return $status;
@@ -748,13 +1400,15 @@
748 1400 * Override parent sanitize_settings to preserve line breaks in link fields
749 1401 *
750 1402 * @since 1.0.0
751 1403 *
752 - * @param array $settings Settings to sanitize
1404 + * @param array $settings Settings to sanitize
1405 + * @param string $context_type Context the save is for.
753 1406 * @return array Sanitized settings
754 1407 */
755 - protected function sanitize_settings(array $settings): array {
1408 + protected function sanitize_settings(array $settings, string $context_type = 'site'): array {
756 1409 $sanitized = [];
1410 + $known = $this->get_known_setting_keys($context_type);
757 1411
758 1412 // Fields that should preserve line breaks
759 1413 $preserve_linebreaks = [
760 1414 'documentation_links',
@@ -771,8 +1425,27 @@
771 1425
772 1426 foreach ($settings as $key => $value) {
773 1427 $sanitized_key = sanitize_key($key);
774 1428
1429 + // Never store the REST envelope back as settings (see
1430 + // Abstract_Seo_Manager::RESERVED_ENVELOPE_KEYS).
1431 + if (in_array($sanitized_key, self::RESERVED_ENVELOPE_KEYS, true)) {
1432 + continue;
1433 + }
1434 +
1435 + // And nothing this manager does not declare (#452).
1436 + if (!$this->is_known_setting_key($sanitized_key, $known)) {
1437 + continue;
1438 + }
1439 +
1440 + // Constrain the delivery mode to the known enum so an unexpected
1441 + // value falls back to auto-detection rather than being stored.
1442 + if ('delivery_mode' === $sanitized_key) {
1443 + $mode = is_string($value) ? sanitize_key($value) : '';
1444 + $sanitized[$sanitized_key] = in_array($mode, self::DELIVERY_MODES, true) ? $mode : 'auto';
1445 + continue;
1446 + }
1447 +
775 1448 if (is_string($value)) {
776 1449 if (in_array($key, $preserve_linebreaks, true)) {
777 1450 // Use our custom sanitization that preserves line breaks
778 1451 if (in_array($key, ['documentation_links', 'technical_links', 'optional_links', 'custom_sections'], true)) {
@@ -916,11 +1589,20 @@
916 1589 }
917 1590
918 1591 // Check key features quality
919 1592 if (!empty($user_input['key_features'])) {
920 - $features = explode("\n", $user_input['key_features']);
921 - $feature_count = count(array_filter($features, 'trim'));
1593 + // The same splitter the generated file uses, so the count reported
1594 + // here and the bullets written out can never disagree (#765).
1595 + $feature_count = count(self::split_key_features((string) $user_input['key_features']));
922 1596
1597 + // A single line containing commas is ambiguous: it is either a
1598 + // legacy comma-separated list or one feature with a comma in it.
1599 + // Rather than guess and risk publishing "and Etsy" as a feature,
1600 + // say so and let the author decide.
1601 + if (self::looks_like_comma_list((string) $user_input['key_features'])) {
1602 + $validation['suggestions'][] = 'Put each key feature on its own line. Commas are treated as part of a feature, not as separators.';
1603 + }
1604 +
923 1605 if ($feature_count < 3) {
924 1606 $validation['warnings'][] = 'Consider adding more key features (3-8 recommended) for comprehensive AI understanding';
925 1607 $validation['score'] -= 10;
926 1608 } elseif ($feature_count > 10) {
@@ -1236,12 +1918,16 @@
1236 1918 $validation['score'] -= 5;
1237 1919 }
1238 1920 }
1239 1921
1240 - // Check file permissions if enabled
1241 - if (!empty($settings['enabled'])) {
1922 + // Check file permissions if enabled. Only the static delivery mode needs
1923 + // a writable root — dynamic delivery keeps the document in the database.
1924 + $mode = $this->resolve_delivery_mode(
1925 + isset($settings['delivery_mode']) ? (string) $settings['delivery_mode'] : null
1926 + );
1927 + if (!empty($settings['enabled']) && 'static' === $mode) {
1242 1928 if (!$this->is_directory_writable(ABSPATH)) {
1243 - $validation['warnings'][] = 'WordPress root directory is not writable, llms.txt cannot be automatically managed';
1929 + $validation['warnings'][] = 'WordPress root directory is not writable, llms.txt cannot be automatically managed. Switch delivery to "Served by WordPress" to publish without writing a file.';
1244 1930 $validation['score'] -= 10;
1245 1931 }
1246 1932 }
1247 1933
@@ -1276,9 +1962,10 @@
1276 1962
1277 1963 // Get file status
1278 1964 $output['file_status'] = $this->get_llms_txt_status();
1279 1965
1280 - // If file exists, get current content safely
1966 + // If a file is published, get its current content safely; otherwise fall
1967 + // back to the stored document that dynamic delivery serves.
1281 1968 if ($output['file_status']['file_exists']) {
1282 1969 $llms_file = ABSPATH . 'llms.txt';
1283 1970 $read_result = $this->safe_file_read($llms_file);
1284 1971 if ($read_result['success']) {
@@ -1286,8 +1973,10 @@
1286 1973 } else {
1287 1974 $output['llms_txt_content'] = '';
1288 1975 $output['file_read_error'] = $read_result['error'];
1289 1976 }
1977 + } else {
1978 + $output['llms_txt_content'] = $this->get_published_content();
1290 1979 }
1291 1980
1292 1981 // Add metadata
1293 1982 $output['metadata'] = [
@@ -1319,8 +2008,9 @@
1319 2008 'development_approach' => '',
1320 2009 'setup_instructions' => '',
1321 2010 'ai_context_custom' => '',
1322 2011 'auto_generate' => false,
2012 + 'delivery_mode' => 'auto',
1323 2013 'last_generated' => null,
1324 2014 // Structured sections for llms.txt spec compliance
1325 2015 'documentation_links' => '',
1326 2016 'technical_links' => '',
@@ -1373,9 +2063,9 @@
1373 2063 ],
1374 2064 'key_features' => [
1375 2065 'type' => 'string',
1376 2066 'title' => 'Key Features',
1377 - 'description' => 'Main features and functionality of your website',
2067 + 'description' => 'Main features and functionality of your website. One feature per line: a comma is treated as part of a feature, not as a separator.',
1378 2068 'default' => '',
1379 2069 'maxLength' => 500
1380 2070 ],
1381 2071 'target_audience' => [
@@ -1425,8 +2115,15 @@
1425 2115 'title' => 'Auto-generate',
1426 2116 'description' => 'Automatically regenerate llms.txt when settings change',
1427 2117 'default' => false
1428 2118 ],
2119 + 'delivery_mode' => [
2120 + 'type' => 'string',
2121 + 'title' => 'Delivery Method',
2122 + 'description' => 'How /llms.txt is served: "static" writes a physical file the web server answers, "dynamic" keeps the document in WordPress and serves it from PHP as UTF-8, "auto" picks static on Apache/LiteSpeed and dynamic elsewhere.',
2123 + 'enum' => self::DELIVERY_MODES,
2124 + 'default' => 'auto'
2125 + ],
1429 2126 'last_generated' => [
1430 2127 'type' => 'string',
1431 2128 'title' => 'Last Generated',
1432 2129 'description' => 'Timestamp of last generation',
@@ -1476,8 +2173,243 @@
1476 2173 return "> " . $description . "\n\n";
1477 2174 }
1478 2175
1479 2176 /**
2177 + * Split the Key Features field into individual features.
2178 + *
2179 + * One feature per line. Commas used to be delimiters too, which meant a
2180 + * single feature that happened to contain one — "Collect reviews from
2181 + * Trustpilot, Google, and Etsy" — was published as three bullets, one of
2182 + * them reading "and Etsy" (#765). Validation counted by newline only, so
2183 + * it reported one feature while the file showed three and never flagged
2184 + * the split.
2185 + *
2186 + * Commas are not a fallback delimiter even when the value has no newlines.
2187 + * A comma inside a feature is ordinary prose and far more likely than a
2188 + * deliberate comma-separated list, and guessing wrong publishes mangled
2189 + * text to the file AI crawlers read. A single-line value with commas is
2190 + * kept whole and validate_content_quality() suggests splitting it, which
2191 + * tells the user what to do instead of quietly deciding for them.
2192 + *
2193 + * The one splitter both generation and validation use, so the file and the
2194 + * feature count can no longer disagree.
2195 + *
2196 + * @since 2.10.0
2197 + *
2198 + * @param string $key_features Raw field value.
2199 + * @return string[] Trimmed features, empties removed.
2200 + */
2201 + public static function split_key_features(string $key_features): array {
2202 + $features = preg_split('/[\r\n]+/', $key_features);
2203 +
2204 + if (!is_array($features)) {
2205 + return [];
2206 + }
2207 +
2208 + $features = array_map('trim', $features);
2209 +
2210 + return array_values(array_filter($features, static fn(string $f): bool => '' !== $f));
2211 + }
2212 +
2213 + /**
2214 + * Whether a value looks like the old comma-separated list.
2215 + *
2216 + * One line, and a comma in it. That is either a legacy list saved before
2217 + * newlines became the delimiter, or a single feature containing a comma —
2218 + * indistinguishable from the outside, which is exactly why this prompts
2219 + * rather than splits.
2220 + *
2221 + * @since 2.10.0
2222 + *
2223 + * @param string $key_features Raw field value.
2224 + * @return bool
2225 + */
2226 + public static function looks_like_comma_list(string $key_features): bool {
2227 + $trimmed = trim($key_features);
2228 +
2229 + if ('' === $trimmed || false !== strpbrk($trimmed, "\r\n")) {
2230 + return false;
2231 + }
2232 +
2233 + return false !== strpos($trimmed, ',');
2234 + }
2235 +
2236 + /**
2237 + * Turn a single-line comma list into one feature per line.
2238 + *
2239 + * Returns null when the value is not something to convert: it already has
2240 + * line breaks, has no comma, or reads as one feature containing a series.
2241 + *
2242 + * Only for text that was written under a comma rule: values saved before
2243 + * newlines became the only delimiter (see
2244 + * {@see self::maybe_migrate_legacy_key_features()}), and AI replies that
2245 + * ignored the one-per-line instruction. Typed input never goes through
2246 + * this; split_key_features() still keeps a comma inside a feature (#765).
2247 + *
2248 + * A series is the one shape the old rule demonstrably mangled: "Collect
2249 + * reviews from Trustpilot, Google, and Etsy" became three bullets, the
2250 + * last reading "and Etsy". So a value is left whole when a segment after
2251 + * the first opens with a conjunction (the Oxford form), or when the final
2252 + * segment carries one ("..., Google and Etsy", the form the field's own
2253 + * placeholder uses). A plain list that happens to end "X and Y" is left
2254 + * whole too; validation still suggests splitting it, and one intact bullet
2255 + * is the safer wrong answer than a sentence cut into fragments.
2256 + *
2257 + * A comma between digits ("1,000 templates") is a thousands separator,
2258 + * not a delimiter.
2259 + *
2260 + * @since 2.10.0
2261 + *
2262 + * @param string $key_features Raw value.
2263 + * @return string|null Newline-separated features, or null to leave as is.
2264 + */
2265 + public static function comma_list_to_lines(string $key_features): ?string {
2266 + if (!self::looks_like_comma_list($key_features)) {
2267 + return null;
2268 + }
2269 +
2270 + $segments = preg_split('/\s*,(?!\d)\s*/', trim($key_features));
2271 +
2272 + if (!is_array($segments)) {
2273 + return null;
2274 + }
2275 +
2276 + $segments = array_values(array_filter(
2277 + array_map('trim', $segments),
2278 + static fn(string $s): bool => '' !== $s
2279 + ));
2280 +
2281 + if (count($segments) < 2) {
2282 + return null;
2283 + }
2284 +
2285 + foreach (array_slice($segments, 1) as $segment) {
2286 + if (preg_match('/^(?:(?:and|or|nor|plus)\b|&)/i', $segment)) {
2287 + return null;
2288 + }
2289 + }
2290 +
2291 + if (preg_match('/\s(?:and|or|&)\s/i', (string) end($segments))) {
2292 + return null;
2293 + }
2294 +
2295 + return implode("\n", $segments);
2296 + }
2297 +
2298 + /**
2299 + * Coerce an AI reply for Key Features into the one-per-line field value.
2300 + *
2301 + * The prompt asks for one feature per line, but models still answer with a
2302 + * JSON array or a comma-separated line. An array went through
2303 + * sanitize_textarea_field() as '' and the field silently kept its old
2304 + * value; a comma line was published as a single bullet now that commas are
2305 + * not delimiters. Both are normalised to lines here, before sanitising.
2306 + *
2307 + * @since 2.10.0
2308 + *
2309 + * @param mixed $value Decoded `key_features` from the reply.
2310 + * @return string Sanitised, newline-separated features.
2311 + */
2312 + public static function normalize_ai_key_features($value): string {
2313 + if (is_array($value)) {
2314 + $features = [];
2315 + foreach ($value as $item) {
2316 + if (is_scalar($item)) {
2317 + $item = trim((string) $item);
2318 + if ('' !== $item) {
2319 + $features[] = $item;
2320 + }
2321 + }
2322 + }
2323 + $value = implode("\n", $features);
2324 + } elseif (!is_scalar($value)) {
2325 + return '';
2326 + }
2327 +
2328 + $value = (string) $value;
2329 + $lines = self::comma_list_to_lines($value);
2330 +
2331 + return sanitize_textarea_field(null === $lines ? $value : $lines);
2332 + }
2333 +
2334 + /**
2335 + * Convert a Key Features value saved under the old comma rule, once.
2336 + *
2337 + * Up to 2.9.0 a comma separated features, so a site that saved
2338 + * "SEO audits, Schema markup, XML sitemaps" published three bullets. After
2339 + * #765 made newlines the only delimiter the same stored value regenerates
2340 + * as one bullet holding the whole line, a silent change to the file AI
2341 + * crawlers read. Rewriting the stored value as lines keeps that site's
2342 + * output what it was, in the form the field now documents.
2343 + *
2344 + * A migration rather than a runtime fallback on purpose: a fallback would
2345 + * keep treating commas as delimiters for every single-line value forever,
2346 + * which is the #765 bug. Here only values that were saved while commas
2347 + * really were delimiters are touched, exactly once; anything typed after
2348 + * this has run follows the new rule. comma_list_to_lines() still leaves a
2349 + * series such as the #765 value whole.
2350 + *
2351 + * Version-gated like Settings::retire_seeded_ai_provider(), and the marker
2352 + * is written first so a site that fails the write does not retry on every
2353 + * admin request. The activator records it on a fresh install.
2354 + *
2355 + * @since 2.10.0
2356 + *
2357 + * @return void
2358 + */
2359 + public static function maybe_migrate_legacy_key_features(): void {
2360 + if (get_option(self::KEY_FEATURES_MIGRATION_OPTION) === self::KEY_FEATURES_MIGRATION_VERSION) {
2361 + return;
2362 + }
2363 +
2364 + update_option(self::KEY_FEATURES_MIGRATION_OPTION, self::KEY_FEATURES_MIGRATION_VERSION, true);
2365 +
2366 + (new static())->migrate_stored_key_features();
2367 + }
2368 +
2369 + /**
2370 + * Rewrite the stored Key Features as lines when it is a legacy comma list.
2371 + *
2372 + * @since 2.10.0
2373 + *
2374 + * @return bool True when a value was converted and saved.
2375 + */
2376 + public function migrate_stored_key_features(): bool {
2377 + $stored = $this->get_stored_settings('site');
2378 +
2379 + if (!isset($stored['key_features']) || !is_string($stored['key_features'])) {
2380 + return false;
2381 + }
2382 +
2383 + $lines = self::comma_list_to_lines($stored['key_features']);
2384 +
2385 + if (null === $lines) {
2386 + return false;
2387 + }
2388 +
2389 + // validate_settings() rejects a payload without `enabled`, so carry the
2390 + // stored flag along. Written through the base save, not this class's,
2391 + // which would also reconcile the delivery mode: a stored-value rewrite
2392 + // must not republish anything.
2393 + return $this->write_migrated_key_features([
2394 + 'enabled' => $stored['enabled'] ?? true,
2395 + 'key_features' => $lines,
2396 + ]);
2397 + }
2398 +
2399 + /**
2400 + * Persist the converted value. Separate so tests can observe the write.
2401 + *
2402 + * @since 2.10.0
2403 + *
2404 + * @param array $settings `enabled` and `key_features`.
2405 + * @return bool
2406 + */
2407 + protected function write_migrated_key_features(array $settings): bool {
2408 + return parent::save_settings('site', null, $settings);
2409 + }
2410 +
2411 + /**
1480 2412 * Build additional details section
1481 2413 *
1482 2414 * @since 1.0.0
1483 2415 *
@@ -1495,18 +2427,10 @@
1495 2427 }
1496 2428
1497 2429 if (!empty($key_features)) {
1498 2430 $content .= "**Key Features:**\n";
1499 - // The UI field is a multi-line textarea and validation counts by
1500 - // newline, so split on newlines (and still tolerate commas) rather
1501 - // than commas only — otherwise newline-separated input collapses
1502 - // into one broken bullet.
1503 - $features = preg_split('/[\r\n,]+/', $key_features);
1504 - foreach ($features as $feature) {
1505 - $feature = trim($feature);
1506 - if (!empty($feature)) {
1507 - $content .= "- " . $feature . "\n";
1508 - }
2431 + foreach (self::split_key_features($key_features) as $feature) {
2432 + $content .= "- " . $feature . "\n";
1509 2433 }
1510 2434 $content .= "\n";
1511 2435 }
1512 2436
@@ -1540,9 +2464,9 @@
1540 2464 $content .= "- [Technical Stack]({$website_url}): Built with {$stack}\n";
1541 2465 }
1542 2466
1543 2467 if (!empty($user_input['development_approach'])) {
1544 - $approach_summary = wp_trim_words($user_input['development_approach'], 10);
2468 + $approach_summary = \ThinkRank\Core\Seo_Text::trim_words($user_input['development_approach'], 10);
1545 2469 $content .= "- [Development Guidelines]({$website_url}): {$approach_summary}\n";
1546 2470 }
1547 2471
1548 2472 // Add robots.txt reference